It’s getting around that time when I’m spending more time working on the game as I realize how many little things need to be fixed, added, tweaked. I’ve recently given up most of my weekends now in an effort to get more hours in. I’m currently working 6 out of the 7 days a week on the game in some way. It’s mostly game programming, sometimes graphics, web development, emailing, phone calls, or getting business forms and other legal stuff squared away.
This week was a rather productive week on several fronts:
- Got a lot of new art assets from Adam and implemented them
- Feedback from testers started trickling in and the reaction has been positive along with tons of great suggestions/ideas
- Fixed a lot of old bugs that were sitting in the queue
- Improved some memory usage of textures
The week wasn’t without it’s headaches though. This completion date graph illustrates just how badly I estimated this week’s tasks:
The amount of tasks was unusually large for the past week, but the amount of tasks wasn’t as big an issue as some tasks taking 10 times longer than I wanted.
The biggest one was getting multi-threaded texture loading on the iPhone working. The hours I logged into getting it working is my own personal testament to how a seemingly simple task can blow up to ridiculous portions when you mention the word “multi-threading”. Had I known it’d take this long I would’ve opted for a more basic solution and leave it to a side project. The bright side is now I can load audio and graphics in parallel along with the main thread being able to continue any animations and such. It took about 20 hours to get it working and debugged, which is somewhat embarrassing haha!
Hair-pulling Threading Issues
It started with me wanting to off load the texture loading to another thread. Simple enough. I’ve done this before on other projects. It took a couple of hours to learn how to get OpenGL setup correctly to allow this. Then I discovered OpenGL wasn’t being the meanie, but a function call from core graphics wasn’t allowing me to call it from a background thread (sometimes…ugh). I researched it for a couple of days while finishing up other things, but wasn’t able to find anything conclusive. I then decided to take the leap and implement my own PNG loader using libpng as a base. I mean really…how hard could it be? Hah…hah…ha…
Saying it was frustrating would be the understatement of the year, and last year. I usually try to avoid copy/pasting code as I like to read and understand the API I’m using so when it DOES break I’m not utterly clueless. Libpng’s interface is rather low-level and not exactly the cleanest. After reading documentation on it for what seemed forever I decided to start with an example program and modify it to fit my needs.
Let’s not forget that I’m an XCode/Unix newbie so getting libpng/zlib working as a static library in XCode was a nightmare for me. I ended up building from the source against the correct config’s and SDK’s for the iPhone to avoid the “invalid architecture” warnings. Next came actually implementing the loading. It looked pretty straight forward in all the examples I saw, except I wanted one feature I didn’t see in any of the sample code: be able to load non-power-of-2 textures onto the iPhone. All of the game’s assets are of various shapes and sizes, and several are non-power of 2. I haven’t taken the time to do proper texture atlasing and I wanted the ability to quickly drop any assets Adam sent me into the game’s folder and load it without fiddling with size alignments and the other mess.
This is where things started to get hairy because I was seeing issues crop up that weren’t necessarily from my code so I was lead astray a lot. The caveat is the iPhone has a rather special way of “compressing” PNGs. It took me a while to understand the implications of this because I could load the PNGs fine but holy shit were they rendering wrong in OpenGL! It finally dawned on me to change the blend function OpenGL was using. Much to my surprise I couldn’t find one that would give me the equivalent alpha blending that I got with premultiplied alpha’s. And I wasn’t about to go back and re-design all the assets. By this time I was pretty comfortable working with libpng and I decided to just write a custom transform function to premultiply the alpha when loading it to mimic the previous technique of loading:
Finally, you can write your own transformation function if none of the existing ones meets your needs. This is done by setting a callback with
- png_set_read_user_transform_fn(png_ptr, read_transform_fn);
You must supply the function
- void read_transform_fn(png_ptr ptr, row_info_ptr row_info, png_bytep data)
See pngtest.c for a working example. Your function will be called after all of the other transformations have been processed.
Alrighty, so now I can load things ~20 hours later. Talk about a huge step backwards. Doing the pre-multiplication at runtime is a trade off of convenience over speed. When it comes time to release the game I might consider doing this prior to compiling so the assets are “cooked”. But doing it at runtime adds about 1-1.5 seconds from my unscientific tests.
What’s amusing was once this was working it took 15 minutes to get multi-threading working. Now I decided to be adventurous and load the audio and graphics on separate threads from the main thread, for a total of 3. Speed tests show it’s on average no faster or slower than having both asset types be loaded in order on a single thread *Shrug*. Oh well, if the iPhone ever gets another core then I’ll be set ;). Ultimately, I now have the freedom to toss asset loading on a background thread while the game continues playing with minimal hit to the frames per second.
This kind of thing is probably a bit advanced and overkill to do for such a simple and small game as Tilt To Live. If I have time (unlikely) over the next several weeks I’ll try to put together a complete code listing for those looking to have more control of their asset loading with libpng on the iPhone.